All entertainment

Entertainment · All of LA

Priscilla Presley loses four claims in fraud lawsuit

A Los Angeles judge dismissed four of 21 claims against Priscilla Presley on Nov. 16, but her $50 million fraud fight with two former advisers goes on.

By LA This Weekend Team · November 18, 20260 views

Illustration of a courtroom bench with stacked case folders and a wooden gavel.

A Los Angeles judge has thrown out four of the 21 claims in the $50 million fraud lawsuit against Priscilla Presley, but the rest of the case will move forward. The ruling came Monday, Nov. 16, in Los Angeles County Superior Court, and Rolling Stone and the Daily Express both reported on it. Presley, 81, is Elvis Presley's former wife and the mother of Lisa Marie Presley. The case is a fight between her and two former business advisers, Brigitte Kruse and Kevin Fialko, over her name, her licensing deals and money.

What to know

  • The ruling. Judge Mark Epstein ruled from the bench and dismissed four claims. Those claims include allegations that Presley interfered with a cosmetics contract and improperly used her own name, image and likeness. Rolling Stone reports that the judge found those allegations "were not sufficiently supported by facts in the complaint." Presley did not win on the rest of the case. She lost her bid to toss out 10 other claims, which relate to fraud, breach of contract, and alleged misuse of company funds. The judge also gave Kruse and Fialko a chance to amend their complaint and revive some dismissed claims under different legal theories.

  • The family passages. Presley asked the court to strike passages about her divorce from Elvis Presley and about Lisa Marie Presley's death in 2023. Judge Epstein called some of the language "gratuitous and mean-spirited." He still declined to strike it, reasoning that striking it would make little difference because the claims were already public, according to Rolling Stone. Lisa Marie died on Jan. 12, 2023, at age 54. The Los Angeles County Medical Examiner found she died of complications from a small bowel obstruction linked to earlier bariatric surgery, according to All About Lawyer. These passages are allegations in the filings, and the court has made no finding about them.

  • What the advisers allege. Kruse, a memorabilia dealer, and Fialko say Presley walked away from companies they formed to capitalize on her name, image and likeness. They say she concealed that she had sold certain rights tied to her name years earlier. All About Lawyer reports that a 2005 deal with Elvis Presley Enterprises was valued around $6.5 million, and that Authentic Brands Group later acquired relevant Elvis licensing interests in 2013. Daily Express reports that the advisers also allege Presley hid a jewelry collection they value at more than $25 million. All About Lawyer notes that no verified tax assessment, criminal charge or judgment supports that claim.

  • What Presley alleges. Presley filed her own lawsuit in Los Angeles in July 2024. It accuses Kruse and Fialko of elder abuse, and she says they misappropriated more than $1 million. Rolling Stone reports that she says she was fraudulently induced to sign agreements giving the pair an 80 percent stake in some of her business ventures. Her lawyer, T. Wayne Harman, said she "continues to seek justice for the manipulation, elder abuse, and financial exploitation that she suffered at the hands of Brigitte Kruse and her co-conspirators." Her attorney also told the Daily Express that the complaint is "one of the most shameful, ridiculous, salacious, and meritless lawsuits I have seen in my practice."

  • Where the case goes next. Kruse and Fialko first sued in Florida in October 2023. The claims then moved to California, and they filed a $50 million cross-complaint last year, according to Rolling Stone. Judge Epstein urged the advisers to act quickly if they want to add a third party, naming Authentic Brands Group. He said, "My goal is to get this done," and called the case "getting really long in the tooth." Harman said Presley "is thankful that her case is moving closer to trial." A lawyer for Kruse and Fialko, Jordan Matthews, said they "intend to vigorously enforce our clients' rights."

  • What is still unknown. No court has found that Presley committed fraud, and no court has ordered her to pay the $50 million sought, according to All About Lawyer. No settlement is verified in the reports. The November ruling was on motions, not on the merits, so the allegations on both sides remain unproven.

What the ruling does and does not decide

The judge did not decide whether any of the claims are true. At this stage the question is whether the complaint says enough to go forward. All About Lawyer notes that letting a claim proceed means it was pleaded well enough for now, not that the allegations are true. The judge also allowed the advisers to amend and try again under different legal theories, potentially including breach of contract.

Who the people in the case are

Brigitte Kruse is an auctioneer and the founder of GWS Auctions, a business that sells entertainment memorabilia, including Elvis Presley items, according to All About Lawyer. Kevin Fialko is described as a business associate who worked with Kruse on ventures involving Presley. The advisers say Presley asked for help rebuilding her brand and income, and they helped form companies meant to commercialize her name and recollections. Presley's side says the pair won her trust, isolated her from longtime advisers and took control of key parts of her financial life. Both accounts are contested, and the judge has not decided between them.

Why the family details came up

Lisa Marie Presley's death is part of the case because the advisers' filings discuss it at length. Presley's lawyers asked the judge to remove those passages, and the judge declined, reasoning that the material was already public. Rolling Stone reports that Presley later reached a settlement with granddaughter Riley Keough that gave her a $1 million lump-sum payment, a $100,000 annual salary and burial rights near Elvis at Graceland, as the outlet reported earlier.

Our take

Presley is one of the most recognizable names in American pop culture, and this case reaches into the parts of her life that were already public: her marriage to Elvis, her daughter's death and the businesses built around the Presley name. The judge's comment that some passages were "gratuitous and mean-spirited" shows why fans care. The question at the center is simple to state and hard to answer. Who had the right to sell her name, and who was owed money when those deals changed?

The Los Angeles angle is the court itself. The case is heard in Los Angeles County Superior Court, where a judge is now pressing both sides to move faster. The judge's frustration with the pace of the litigation is a reminder that a famous name does not make a case move quickly. Many readers in the city will have watched other high-profile cases stall for years.

These stories are easy to read as a verdict, and they are not one. Keep the claims and the denials side by side, and watch what the next filings say.

Does the public have a stake in how a famous family's business fights are settled?

Where this comes from

This comes from Rolling Stone's Nov. 16 report by Nancy Dillon on the hearing and the judge's ruling, the Daily Express US report published Nov. 17 on the advisers' allegations and Presley's attorney's response, and All About Lawyer's Nov. 17 explainer on the case timeline, court dates and background.


What do you think? Tell us in the comments below, or post about it on the community board.

LA This Weekend Team

0 comments

Keep it neighborly. Comments that attack people get removed.

Log in or create a free account to join the conversation.

Log in to comment