All news

Housing · All of LA

Lawsuit seeks to block HUD rule on mixed-status families in public housing

Public Counsel and tenant groups sued HUD to block a rule that could force mixed-status families in public housing to separate or lose aid. It takes effect Dec. 14.

By LA This Weekend Team · November 18, 20260 views

Illustration of neighbors and families gathered in a sunny Los Angeles apartment courtyard. Not a real photo of the event.

A Los Angeles nonprofit law firm and tenant groups sued the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development late Monday to block a new rule that would require people in federally funded public housing to prove qualifying immigration status, the Los Angeles Times reported. ABC7 reported that the legal challenge was announced at Public Counsel's Koreatown office. The rule is scheduled to take effect Dec. 14.

Newsweek reported that the complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California against HUD and Secretary Scott Turner. The plaintiffs are three Los Angeles County residents and two tenant organizations, People Organized for Westside Renewal, known as POWER, and Unión de Vecinos. Public Counsel, Kendall Brill & Kelly LLP and Bird Marella LLP are on the case, according to Newsweek.

For decades, mixed-status families could live together in federally assisted homes. Assistance was prorated, so it covered only eligible household members. Westside Current reported that this arrangement has been allowed since 1995. The new rule changes that. Newsweek reported that it removes a “do not contend” option, which let household members decline to claim eligible status, and it expands verification requirements. Plaintiffs argue that the change would effectively end prorated assistance for many mixed-status households.

The local numbers are large. The Los Angeles Times reported that the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, known as HACLA, says 7,700 individuals in the city live in mixed-status households inside public housing. Westside Current cited the same agency's estimate of about 1,700 mixed-status families. Newsweek, citing HUD figures from the lawsuit, reported that about 79,300 people, including roughly 36,000 children, live in mixed-status households that receive HUD assistance. ABC7 reported that more than a third of the people expected to be affected live in California.

The stakes are personal for many households. Under the rule, a family that keeps an ineligible member at home could lose assistance for at least two years, Newsweek reported. Councilmember Eunisses Hernandez, whose district includes William Mead Homes, one of the oldest public housing communities in the city, told ABC7 that the proposal would add pressure to families already facing high costs. Kathryn Eidmann, president and chief executive of Public Counsel, said: “For 30 years, mixed-status families have lived together in public housing and Section 8 homes.”

Public Counsel attorney Amanda Mangaser Savage told Newsweek: “No family should have to choose between staying together and keeping a roof over their heads.” HUD defends the rule. Turner told ABC7 that it “fully implements federal law” and “guarantees only American citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing.” Westside Current reported that HUD said an audit found nearly 200,000 tenants with incomplete or unknown eligibility verification.

The city is also pushing back. Westside Current reported that Councilwoman Traci Park joined four colleagues in introducing a resolution opposing the rule. Co-sponsors are Eunisses Hernandez, Curren Price, Ysabel Jurado and Tim McOsker. The resolution would add opposition to the city's federal legislative agenda and direct the housing authority, the City Attorney's Office and other departments to coordinate help for affected residents. The council had voted unanimously in February against the proposed version of the rule.

A lawsuit does not stop a rule on its own. The plaintiffs ask a judge to postpone the effective date and bar enforcement in California's Central District, and ultimately to declare the policy unlawful, ABC7 reported. Westside Current noted that the rule includes documentation deadlines and transition provisions, so the effective date does not mean every affected family would lose aid right away.

What to know

  • The rule takes effect Dec. 14, according to ABC7 and Newsweek.
  • Public Counsel and two tenant groups filed suit in federal court Monday, Newsweek reported.
  • HACLA says 7,700 individuals in the city live in mixed-status households in public housing, the Times reported.
  • The rule removes the “do not contend” option and expands verification, Newsweek reported.
  • The rule includes documentation deadlines and transition provisions, Westside Current reported.

Our take

A rule taking effect is not the same as families losing their homes overnight. The transition steps matter, and so do the deadlines. For a household with a citizen child and a relative who is not eligible, though, the choice the rule describes is a hard one, and the people living it are the ones who will feel it first.

If you live in a household that mixes immigration status, or you work with tenants who do, tell us what information would help most right now. Are the deadlines clear to you?

Sources


What do you think? Tell us in the comments below, or post about it on the community board.

LA This Weekend Team

0 comments

Keep it neighborly. Comments that attack people get removed.

Log in or create a free account to join the conversation.

Log in to comment