Metro weighs a Sherman Oaks mall parking lot for a rail yard
Metro is considering the Westfield Fashion Square parking lot for a rail maintenance yard. Hundreds of residents packed a meeting Monday, and comments are open until Nov. 23.
By LA This Weekend Team · November 18, 20260 views

Metro is considering a rail maintenance and storage yard in the parking lot of Westfield Fashion Square in Sherman Oaks. Hundreds of residents turned out Monday to oppose the idea. NBC Los Angeles, KTLA, ABC7 and CBS Los Angeles all reported on the meeting. Metro says no decision has been made.
NBC Los Angeles reported that Metro said the mall would not close if it moved forward with the Fashion Square option, and that the yard would sit in the mall's current parking lot. ABC7 reported that Metro officials said they do not want the mall itself, and that if buying the parking lot required buying the mall, the proposal would not move forward.
The yard would serve the Sepulveda Transit Corridor Project. KTLA described the project as a Metro initiative to build a high-capacity rail line that would give the San Fernando Valley and the Westside a north-south connection, and eventually reach Los Angeles International Airport. At the center of the current debate is a new half-mile-long rail maintenance facility. NBC Los Angeles reported that the line will run from the Valley to LAX.
KTLA listed the five possible sites. The first is the existing Westfield Fashion Square lot on Riverside Drive. The second is Oxnard Street between Kester Avenue and Sepulveda Boulevard. The third is existing Metro parking near the G Line Van Nuys Station and adjacent properties. The fourth is land north of Victory Boulevard, just west of Van Nuys Boulevard. The fifth is The Plant shopping center and adjacent properties east of Van Nuys Boulevard.
Metro explained why the mall made the list. CBS Los Angeles quoted a Metro statement: “The Westfield site was identified because a large part of that site is parking lots and because it is nestled next to the freeway.” Metro said it is conducting public scoping on that site and several others it may evaluate for a maintenance and storage facility.
The mall is what drew the crowd. KTLA reported that the meeting was the fifth and final community session on the site, and that residents packed the room and stood outside. One resident told the meeting: “We want to know from you that you're not going to tear down our mall.” Another, Tom Jones, said Metro should keep the yard on city-owned property and build it in the industrial areas of Van Nuys, KTLA reported.
Residents raised several concerns. Sherman Oaks resident Harvey Riff asked, “Why do they need 'that' parking lot? There are so many other alternatives and ways they could build construction of this,” ABC7 reported. Jeanette Onorati said the site is bad for the school across the street and for nearby neighborhoods. Phillip Schenkler raised environmental concerns about dust and pollution from a servicing center reaching the Los Angeles River. Michael Pines, who has lived in the area for more than 30 years, told NBC Los Angeles he worried about what a maintenance yard would do to property values.
Some residents also feared the mall could be at risk even if it were not torn down. ABC7 reported that some worried Metro could later expand the facility. Hope Grossman called the mall “an iconic place for the valley.”
Metro's response has been that it is still early. Spokesperson Janel Steinberg told KTLA: “We want people to weigh in. Right now, we're at the very beginning of the process. No decisions have been made.” Ray Sosa, Metro's chief planning officer, told the crowd, according to ABC7: “We'll take that input very seriously as we move ahead in the study so we can potentially reduce the number of alternatives that we're looking at.” KTLA reported that a preliminary decision could come by spring.
What to know
- Metro is weighing five sites for a rail maintenance and storage facility for the Sepulveda Transit Corridor Project, KTLA reported.
- The Fashion Square option would place the yard in the mall's current parking lot, NBC Los Angeles reported.
- Metro says the mall would not close under that option, NBC Los Angeles reported.
- Public comments are accepted through Nov. 23, NBC Los Angeles reported.
- KTLA reported that a preliminary decision could be announced by spring.
Our take
The anger in that room is about more than one parking lot. It is about whether a neighborhood gets a say before a big project shows up on the map. Metro is saying the right things about listening, and it has a clear window to act on them. Narrowing five sites to fewer is the test.
If you live near the mall, the Oxnard Street corridor or the Van Nuys sites, comments are open until Nov. 23. Would you rather see the yard in the mall lot, on Oxnard Street, or in the industrial areas Tom Jones described? Tell us in the comments below.
Sources
- KTLA: Popular San Fernando Valley shopping mall may be torn down, and the community outraged
- ABC7 Los Angeles: Proposed Metro rail yard at Westfield Fashion Square Mall parking lot sparks anger, frustration among Sherman Oaks residents
- NBC Los Angeles: Metro's proposal to build train maintenance facility draws ire in Sherman Oaks
- CBS Los Angeles: Metro proposal for Westfield Fashion Square enrages Sherman Oaks residents
File photo: Interior of Westfield Fashion Square in Sherman Oaks by Cbl62, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
What do you think? Tell us in the comments below, or post about it on the community board.
LA This Weekend Team









